Northern Ireland just wasted five million pounds on a vehicle testing contract that built nothing
Northern Ireland's spending watchdog says a failed contract to upgrade vehicle testing centres wasted more than five million pounds and delivered nothing.
The NI Audit Office published its report a few hours ago.
Dorinnia Carville wrote it. She is the Comptroller and Auditor General for Northern Ireland.
So what happened?
The Driver and Vehicle Agency signed a contract seven years ago, back in 2019. It was worth ten point eight million pounds.
The firm on the other side has been identified by the BBC as Worldwide Environmental Products Inc.
The plan was simple. New testing equipment at two centres, Hydebank and Mallusk. Together they would add capacity for two hundred thousand extra vehicle tests a year.
None of that happened.
Dorinnia Carville says quote "a significant waste of public money".
So how did it go wrong?
Well, start with the price. The winning bid came in at ten point eight million pounds. That's just over half the only other compliant bid. And well below the DVA's own estimate of around eighteen million pounds.
The DVA followed the correct procurement rules. It even ran further checks.
But those checks did not prove the work could actually be done at that price.
And here's the first warning sign. Within six months, the contractor was six weeks behind schedule.
By February 2022, the DVA had issued two formal warnings for poor performance. It tried to end the contract there.
The contractor fought back. And won.
A High Court judge ruled the contract never set clear dates for putting key systems in place. So the firm blocked the termination.
So the DVA kept going. For three more years, it tried to make the deal work.
Now, why did it really fall apart?
Dorinnia Carville points to limited scrutiny of the proposed IT solution. That became a major source of disagreement between the two sides.
The contract was finally ended in April 2025, through a settlement. Every piece of equipment that had gone in came back out again.
That's 19 months ago. Almost six years after the contract was first signed.
Comments
None yetAlready a member? Log in.




