A Stormont minister just accepted his department got a cattle cull badly wrong
Northern Ireland's Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir has just accepted every single recommendation from an independent review into a cattle cull that caused outcry across the farming community.
So what was the review?
It was published three days ago. Dr Martin Blake, the former chief veterinary officer of Ireland, carried it out.
He looked at how the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, known as DAERA, culled 51 cattle near Fivemiletown in County Tyrone.
That was about four and a half months ago, on 29 and 30 June.
Here's why the cull happened at all. It was enforcing a court order. The animals' keeper had already been banned for life from keeping livestock over animal welfare offences.
And the review found the cull itself was lawful. The method used was humane. Appropriate too, from an animal welfare standpoint.
But here's the part DAERA got wrong.
Planning was poor. Communication was poor. Record-keeping was poor. Risk assessment was poor. And clearing the site afterwards was poor too.
The review found carcasses were left exposed in fields overnight. That caused more distress.
And here's the root cause. Staff had no up-to-date written policy to follow. So they worked from historical custom and practice instead.
Now, why does any of this matter to the public?
Images and videos of the carcasses in those fields went online in early July. They caused real anger.
Hundreds of farmers protested at Stormont in August. They called for Andrew Muir to resign. The Ulster Farmers' Union said then it had lost confidence in senior DAERA leadership.
Andrew Muir commissioned the Blake review himself, in July, after seeing the images and hearing the anger.
A DUP motion of no confidence in him was defeated by 38 votes to 32 just over five weeks ago. So he stayed in post.
Comments
None yetAlready a member? Log in.





