Russia just rejected Trump's Ukraine NATO trade and the peace deal mentions no Ukraine
2 days ago · 20 November 2026Share
President Donald J. Trump participates in a pull-aside meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin during the APEC Summit in Shenzhen, China, Thursday, November 19, 2026. File photo. The White House · Public domain
Ukraine gives up the eastern Donbas region. In return, it gets a security guarantee like NATO's mutual defence clause.
So what actually happened? Trump and Putin met for about 40 minutes at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China, a day ago. A Kremlin aide, Yuri Ushakov, says Ukraine was the main topic.
After that, Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping held a first-ever three-way summit at Kylin Villa. It ran about 90 minutes.
And here's the twist. That summit produced a joint declaration, put out by China's state news agency, Xinhua. It has four points.
None of them mentions Ukraine.
So the summit that was supposed to be about Ukraine ended with a peace statement that doesn't say the word Ukraine once.
This trade didn't start in Shenzhen, either. Six days ago, Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine's President, said American negotiators had raised it with him for the first time, in talks in Abu Dhabi.
Zelensky says the Americans put a question to him directly: would Ukraine join NATO if it withdrew from Donbas.
That's the trade he says was raised with him first.
Zelensky says he won't give up Ukrainian territory on his own authority. Any full package, including NATO and EU guarantees, would have to go to a public vote in Ukraine.
And here's what's missing. The White House has not confirmed it put that idea to him. Trump's envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, haven't given any details of what was discussed in Abu Dhabi or in earlier talks in Moscow.
Then, a day ago, Kushner said more about it in public than anyone on the American side had before.
The rest of this story is for members.
Map of the situation in Donbas during the Russo-Ukrainian war. File photo. Rr016 · CC BY-SA 4.0
He was in Berlin, after a Coalition of the Willing summit hosted by the leaders of Germany, France and Britain. He said Trump is open to giving Ukraine a guarantee like NATO's Article 5 — the clause that says an attack on one member is an attack on all of them.
Kushner says Russia has been brought round to that idea, with any security guarantee for Ukraine built on Article Five.
That's Trump's own envoy saying Russia is comfortable with treating an attack on Ukraine as an attack on NATO.
But no Russian official has said that. The opposite is on the record, again and again.
Three days before Kushner spoke, Sergei Ryabkov, Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister, said Russia will not accept Ukraine joining NATO, under any circumstances.
In Shenzhen, Putin didn't contradict that. He told reporters the three countries have, in his words, numerous shared interests in settling regional conflicts, including Ukraine's. But he also blamed Kyiv and its European backers for the war. He said nothing about accepting NATO membership for Ukraine.
And Russia's minimum demands haven't moved. Full control of the Donbas. And Ukraine giving up its NATO bid entirely.
Those two demands cancel out Kushner's version of events.
There's more. Eight days before Shenzhen, at the Kremlin, Putin told Witkoff and Kushner directly that any European troops stationed in Ukraine after a ceasefire would be unacceptable. Ushakov says Putin also reminded them of Moscow's old demand to roll NATO's military presence back to where it stood in 1997 — before the alliance expanded into Eastern Europe at all.
So the gap here isn't small. Kushner says Russia is comfortable with NATO-style protection for Ukraine. Russia's own officials, Putin included, keep saying Ukraine in NATO is not acceptable at all.
So which one is true? Nobody outside the room knows yet.
Zelensky, speaking before the Shenzhen summit, said Trump and Xi Jinping could still pressure Putin into ending the war, in his words, if they don't play any games.
For now, the only document that came out of Shenzhen does not mention Ukraine. The trade supposedly behind it has been described by an American envoy, contradicted in substance by Russian officials, and not addressed directly by either Putin or Trump.
Who would want a Trump/Kushner deal. ? FFS. It'll be wrapped around property deal for Kushner, If not both of them. and it'll leak like a sieve. lauriemillerjade.com
2 days ago
Readers, not advertisers
This reporting was funded entirely by readers.
Nothing here was paid for by an advertiser. Members are the entire business model. Bronze is where it starts, and it opens the last seven days in full.